Nespresso v/s Keurig Coffee Makers – The Ultimate Battle

Simon Calvin
Written by
Last update:

Similarities

The first thing that interests the coffee lovers in both Nespresso and Keurig is that they are both single serve coffee brewers. Originally, to make coffee in Nespresso or Keurig, you needed to use either pre-packed pods or used a K-cup. The pods and K-cups are convenient for a single use but they are not recyclable or compostable. Soon we come to know that both of these machines provide better variety and maybe that is the difference between these two and the single serve coffeemakers.

They may serve the same purpose of making a single cup of coffee but they have their own identity. They are different in some ways and similar in some ways. You can find some astonishing differences between Nespresso and Keurig. They have their own convenience and their own disadvantages. It is really difficult to say which one is better than the other.

Keurig K-Cups VS Nespresso Capsules

The popular Keurig K cups and Nespresso capsules have a lot of similarities and even more differences and contrasts.

What exactly is a Nespresso machine? The Nespresso concept was developed by a company called Nestle. The company was trying to capitalize on the growing market for single-cup coffee makers. Unfortunately, although it was marketed very well, the Nespresso didn’t launch into an instant success. After a few years, however, it started to gain ground in Europe and slowly became more popular all over the world. It is a capsule-based system, with the capsules being manufactured by a company called Nespresso.

Nespresso machines work with capsules only, and you cannot brew coffee with those capsules, as you can do with Keurig machines. The Nespresso capsules can be quite pricey. The first issue that comes to mind is that they are all the same price, regardless of the brand. It’s not like you can get a cheaper capsule of some obscure brand; everything in the Nespresso store is the very same price.

K-Cups

People are increasingly using environmentally friendly gadgets that are reusable instead of multiple-use or disposable items. Therefore, we’ve brought you a comparison review of the Keurig Coffee Makers v/s Nespresso coffee machines. These two brands use completely different methods to brew coffee, and both have loyal followers. Which brand comes out on top in terms of quality, price, and popularity?

The one thing that Keurig machines and Nespresso machines have in common is the use of coffee capsules as the physical medium for containing the coffee grounds. Both systems rely on perfectly sized coffee grounds to brew quality beverages. With Nespresso, however, you can choose from an infinite variety of manufacturer-made Nespresso capsules. With Keurig, on the other hand, you’re limited by the finite number of K-Cups available.

Another thing that Nespresso and Keurig share is the use of high-quality coffee beans. Both brands offer a wide range of beans from different locations and roasts. Coffee enthusiasts agree that there’s no substitute for freshly ground and brewed coffee, and these coffee makers cater to that preference.

Let’s take a look at some of the other differences between Keurig and Nespresso brewing methods.

Nespresso Capsules

Even though Nespresso machines are quite expensive in the long run, many first-time buyers consider it worthwhile. After all, the Nespresso capsule coffee costs about the same as buying gourmet coffee in a cafe.

The high cost of Nespresso also means that many casual coffee drinkers will probably avoid it, so the appeal is mainly to people who drink a lot of coffee, but not enough to justify an expensive espresso machine.

They also avoid people who prefer cheaper coffee or employees of office coffee services, as they typically buy in bulk for cheaper prices.

The consumer culture of gourmet coffee has been growing by leaps and bounds, and the global coffee market has grown by 9 percent in recent years. But the Nespresso capsules are closing in on 70 percent of that market as well.

What it really comes down to is that Nespresso has done profoundly well due to the fact that the coffee-shop experience can now be brought to the comfort of your home. Nespresso machines are becoming more affordable, and the capsules are the major reason for this shift. Not only have the prices come down, but the Nespresso capsules have gone from being in large metal cans to being neatly boxed and stored.

Coffee Brands

Like many people I too love coffee. I am often found in my local coffee shop, sipping on a cup of piping hot cup of coffee. The smell of coffee always makes me feel good. Sometimes I would go to the extent of buying a coffee machine at home, even though my office has one. There is a never-ending debate going on about which coffee machine performs better and which offers better value for money. The Nespresso and Keurig coffee machines are two of the most popular and widely used machines. It is not uncommon to see these two coffee machines in offices, kitchens, and in homes. If you are looking to buy a coffee machine, these two brands should definitely be considered. Both coffee machines meet almost all the requirements that people look for in a coffee machine. So what makes these de luxe coffee machines unique (if at all)? Are they really any different from one another? And which is a better buy? Let’s find out!

Variety

The quality of coffee produced by a Nespresso machine is absolutely incomparable to anything that you can get from a Keurig. Whether you're after a rich espresso or subtle Americano, the Nespresso is up to the challenge. There is an extensive range of coffee varieties to choose from, including some exotic ones, for that perfect blend … and they all provide the same consistent level of deliciousness. The Keurig, on the other hand, is mostly limited to its proprietary coffee pods … not sure about the taste but it must be pretty high quality.

The quality of coffee is a function of freshness … coffee absorbs flavor and loses its aroma with time. So imagine if somebody hands you a cup of coffee that's been sitting around for a few days … yikes!

You know the fresh coffee in a Nespresso machine is the real deal because of the small, auto-sealable aluminum pods. They are like little airtight pods that lock in freshness. It's like the gift inside a gift, and you don't even have to waste time wrapping it or get your fingers soggy! They're also perfect for travel. One of the downsides of a Nespresso machine though is that you can't use your own ground coffee.

Coffee Quality

One of the biggest differences is the coffee quality. Nespresso machines are known to grind the coffee beans better and provide better quality coffee.

Usually, the Nespresso capsules are used within 24 hours of purchase. They provide almost equal quality of coffee if heated immediately after opening and then again after around 30-40 minutes. Keurig pods are more recommended for coffee that needs long term storage.

Nespresso machines are known to grind the coffee beans much better and provide better quality coffee.

Brewing Time

When it comes to brewing time, Nespresso and Keurig are almost on the same lines, with around 25 sec. to 1 min.

It may not seem much but considering the fact that you could make a cuppa coffee in 60 sec. with Nespresso, Keurig’s brewing time is slightly longer.

Aesthetics and Design

Design is the first thing that comes to mind when you think of these two coffee makers. Nespresso –taking design standards from the original "espresso" machines. This coffee maker looks like a futuristic spaceship. It is stylish, compact and elegant. You can choose to go for any color and it will match and fit in with any kitchen counter top.

Keurig – is a compact, stylish, rectangular, black box with lots of buttons. This is a very common design and a tried and tested design when it comes to coffee makers. It can also be in any color, just as long as it's black.

Bells and Whistles

At the risk of sounding uneducated, I’ll admit I could care less about bells and whistles in my coffee maker. I just want a coffee maker that makes good coffee. Still, I know there are a lot of coffee geeks out there who can’t make that same claim about their favorite coffee maker. Here’s how Nespresso and Keurig stack up on the things that coffee geeks care about:

Party time! Though the Nespresso came out on top of our Miniature Coffeemaker Battle , we knew it was only a matter of time until it would face off against a different kind of coffee maker, Keurig.

The diagram above shows the results of the Nespresso and the Keurig being put under the microscope. A close look would reveal that they differ in several key areas. The way we set this up to test the Nespresso and the Keurig featured the Nespresso Pixie and the Keurig K45 Elite. (We also tested a sample size Keurig K55).

Cost Effectiveness

Which one is better?

If you are a coffee lover, then you must be aware of Nespresso and Keurig coffee maker. In the last few years, both the brands have emerged as giants in the world of coffee makers.

Before we compare them, let’s first understand the difference between both of them. Keurig coffee maker has a K-cup, which is a single use plastic pod containing coffee grounds. The pod is filled with the exact amount of coffee grounds which is required to make a single serving of coffee, tea, or hot chocolate. The K-cup gets punctured in the machine, and the water is pumped through it. A cup of coffee is generated in just few minutes.

The Nespresso coffee maker is designed for the passionate coffee lovers. It comes in two forms – one where you can alter your own blends and the other where you can purchase Nespresso’s special blends. The special blends feature different types of coffee (e.g. coffees from Italy or South America). An espresso is generated within a couple of minutes, and you can choose from various types of coffees and milk.

Nespresso machines can be called compact, which makes them the best option for small kitchens. Keurig machines are bulky yet powerful, and its buttons and visual display are very user-friendly.

Warranty and Build Quality

When it comes to super automatic coffee makers, quality beats all. The Keurig seems like it is made of cheap plastic which is not at all impressive considering the price of the machine. There is video of a Keurig from 2010 that was able to brew a cup of coffee within 90 seconds, but it had a lot of design flaws. The newer models are a little more sturdily build but still nothing compared to the Nespresso machine.

The Nespresso has a solid aluminium case which is very sturdy and does not make any noise. The designers have been very careful about every detail and seem to have taken into consideration every possible scenario. Every component is built to the highest standard. The plastic cover on the capsules is black, while there are silver colour on metal parts making the appliance look very premium.

There are a lot of complaints with the Keurig. The most important ones like leaks or poor quality glaswear, have been addressed on newer models but the drawbacks of this model still persist. The coffee that the machine makes might also be of inferior quality. The Nespresso system produces high quality espresso.

Best of the Best

Nespresso Vue v/s Keurig

The world of coffee machines is currently dominated by two players: Nespresso and Keurig. Nespresso has, to put it mildly, staked out its territory and is the undisputed king of the single-serve coffee makers. Keurig, on the other hand, is still relatively new and has a lot of ground to cover before it truly establishes itself as a viable alternative. So which one is better? Let’s begin with a short Nespresso vs. Keurig review and a quick look at the similarities and differences between the two.

Both Nespresso and Keurig offer (generally) the same types of brewing mechanisms: capsules and K-cups.

Nespresso uses slightly larger capsules that are made of aluminium and are hermetically sealed compartments. They are used during espresso brewing. The capsules are inserted inside a coffee machine and then brewed with hot pressurised water. The capsule ends up with a layer of brewed espresso on a bed of finely ground coffee.

Keurig machines use K-cups, which are made of plastic. The difference is in the brewing mechanisms: Nespresso uses hot pressurised water and Keurig machines use filter baskets.

Best Value for the Money

The Nespresso Inissia espresso machine is simply the best espresso maker for most people, especially if you’re looking for the best value for your money. It’s got a lot of great features for the price. It’s not nearly as well known as the Keurig coffee maker, but it has better reviews on Amazon with an overall rating of 4.5 out of 5, compared to 3.9 out of 5 for the Keurig K-Mini Plus.

Brewing espresso requires some skill. But if you’re a rookie, don’t worry – the Nespresso has three levers, and you choose the one that matches your experience. If you’re a beginner, stick with the 2nd lever. More experienced coffee drinkers can use the 3rd lever.

There are three brew sizes to choose from – small, large, and extra large. It takes roughly 40 seconds to brew any of the three sizes.

Who Should Choose Keurig

Coffee Makers?

A Keurig coffee maker is an oddity when measured against conventional coffee makers. The design is such that it resembles more to a mini variety of a drip coffee maker. The coffee maker has been designed in such a way that it can be placed on the counter or on the shelf (for owners looking for a space-saving piece).

The coffee maker produces coffee in just minutes which is unlike the conventional coffee machines that takes significant time.

If you are looking for the best consumer coffee machine, then Keurig brewer is your answer with its perfect features.

Who Should Choose Nespresso?

Nespresso coffee makers are really great machines. They make great coffee with the use of fresh coffee pods. This allows you to avoid overpriced, stale or faulty coffee. They also maintain the integrity of your coffee as the pods help preserve the freshness of your coffee.

Nespresso coffee makers are especially brilliant for people who want an easy way to make a great coffee within minutes on a daily basis.

If you fit into any of these categories, then you will find Nespresso to be a great investment –.

If you can afford to spend a few hundred dollars on a home coffee maker, Nespresso is perfect for you.

If you are someone who cannot make a good cup of coffee with regular percolators or espresso machines.

If you hate waiting around to get a great cup of coffee. Nespresso is perfect for you as it only takes about three minutes from pressing the button until the first sip of coffee is quenching your thirst.

If you are running short on time and need to have a quick beverage. Technology has made it possible for people to have coffee at the push of a button.

If you are traveling a lot, Nespresso is really ideal for you. All you need is a cup, hot water, a power source and you can enjoy your coffee just about anywhere.

If you really want to make the most out of your coffee.